Showing posts with label Mozilla. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mozilla. Show all posts

Monday, January 25, 2010

Mozilla takes on YouTube video choice

A disagreement between Google and Mozilla is making a once-obscure debate into a real issue for those who watch Web video or host it on their own sites.

Last week, Google's YouTube announced early support for HTML5 video, which can be built directly into Web pages and viewed with browsers without relying on a plug-in such as Adobe Systems' Flash, Microsoft's Silverlight, or Apple's QuickTime. Another Web video site, Vimeo, followed suit.

Native video on a Web page sounds nice, and many Web companies support the effort broadly. But there's one big devil in its detail: the HTML5 specification, still under development, doesn't say which "codec" technology should be used to encode and decode video, and different browsers and Web sites support different standards.

YouTube, which delivers vastly more video streams over the Web than any competitor, has come down on one side of the divide, supporting the H.264 codec for HTML5 video on its TestTube site. But after Google made the move, several involved in developing Mozilla's Firefox browser began preaching a royalty-free alternative called Ogg Theora.

Mozilla grew to its present status of second-place browser in large measure by the power of word of mouth, and there's evidence the Mozilla community has begun making itself heard. After an Ogg Theora petition request on a Mozilla mailing list, requests for Ogg Theora support are on both on the YouTube product top ideas and hot ideas list.

Google wouldn't comment on whether it plans to add Ogg Theora support or what it would take to convince it to do so. However, it did leave the door open.

"Support for HTML5 is just a TestTube experiment at this time and a starting point. We can't comment specifically on what codecs we intend to support, but we're open to supporting more of them over time. At the very least we hope to help further this active and ongoing discussion," the company said in a statement.

$5 million licensing fee

Mozilla would have to pay $5 million to license the H.264 codec from MPEG-LA, the industry group that oversees the technology, said Mike Shaver, Mozilla's vice president of engineering in a blog post, and that doing so wouldn't grant rights of those such as Linux operating system companies who build products employing Mozilla's browser.

"These license fees affect not only browser developers and distributors, but also represent a toll booth on anyone who wishes to produce video content. And if H.264 becomes an accepted part of the standardized Web, those fees are a barrier to entry for developers of new browsers, those bringing the Web to new devices or platforms, and those who would build tools to help content and application development," Shaver said.

Nothing requires only one video technology to prevail. After all, different graphics formats including JPEG, GIF, and PNG are in wide use today on the Web, and today's widely used Flash technology for video will remain a fixture for years.

But supporting multiple standards takes developer time and makes Web sites more complicated. So, in the absence of a prevailing standard, Web site developers are more likely to sit on the sidelines.

A long-running issue

The difficulties have been brewing for months behind the scenes in the HTML5 standardization process. The standard's editor, Google employee Ian Hickson, decided last year against specifying a video codec in the HTML5 standard. "After an inordinate amount of discussions, both in public and privately, on the situation regarding codecs for video and audio in HTML5, I have reluctantly come to the conclusion that there is no suitable codec that all vendors are willing to implement and ship," he said in a blog post.

HTML5 video support is just arriving in Web browsers. Firefox of course supports Ogg Theora, and Opera is working on it. Apple's Safari, though, supports H.264. Internet Explorer supports neither, and Google's Chrome supports both.

YouTube and Vimeo support H.264, but not all have gone that route. Dailymotion and Wikipedia embraced Ogg Theora

Most Web sites will have to protect users from this confusion by checking what browser they're using and delivering an appropriately formatted Web page. If a desired HTML5 video format isn't supported, the Web page can fall back to Flash.

But HTML5 video offers some mechanisms for tighter integration with the Web page than Flash. To take advantage of that, developers would have to offer substantially different versions of their Web pages--one with the integration and one without it.

'Something very dangerous'

Mozilla's reflex to steer clear of patent-encumbered technology isn't academic. Unisys started seeking licensing revenue for the GIF format based on compression patents it held, but didn't start until 1999, years after the format grew popular.

"Most people don't understand that something very dangerous is taking place behind the scenes," said Chris Blizzard, who leads developer relations for Mozilla. "Unisys was asking some Web site owners $5,000 to $7,500 to able to use GIFs on their sites...We're looking at the same situation with H.264, except at a far larger scale."

And YouTube's move is a big step toward cementing H.264's position in HTML5 video, he argued.

"Their choice for H.264 had an immediate effect. It's a signal to the market that it's OK to start using H.264 as the main codec for HTML5 video," Blizzard said.

The prevailing wisdom is that H.264 offers superior quality over Ogg Theora. But Blizzard argues that Mozilla has helped the Xiph project from which the Ogg Theora format came is better, and the Ogg Vorbis audio-only codec is superior to MP3: "On the quality side what we've been able to do at Mozilla, with the help of the rest of the Xiph community, is to show that even though Theora is based on older, royalty-free technology, it does at least as well as H.264 in practice (although not always in theory.)"

Mozilla programmer Robert O'Callahan raised another issue: H.264 licensing fees could increase.

"Currently providing H.264 content on the Internet is zero-cost, but after 2010 that will almost certainly change," O'Callahan said. "We won't know much about the terms until the end of this month. The key issue is not exactly how much it will cost, but that if you want to publish H.264 you will probably have to hire lawyers and negotiate a license with the MPEG-LA.

Cutting the Gordian Knot

If this situation seems insufficiently complicated, there's another wrinkle that could come from Google.

But this one has the potential to simplify things.

That's because Google is trying to acquire On2 Technologies, the company whose earlier codec work underlies the Ogg formats. In Google's announcement of the planned acquisition, Sundar Picahai, Google's vice president of product management, had this tantalizing rationale to offer: "Today video is an essential part of the Web experience, and we believe high-quality video compression technology should be a part of the Web platform."

Of course, Google first must convince the On2 shareholders to agree, and it's had to sweeten the offer already. After that, it would have to convince browser companies and others involved in HTML standardization to go along with the idea--and it should be noted that browser makers Microsoft and Apple have patents covered by H.264.

But Apple has a growing media business through iTunes--and its Lala acquisition shows it has some interest in streaming media, too. Microsoft, meanwhile, has begun professing enthusiasm for Web standards.

So while the Web is guaranteed years of changes in Web video--if indeed it ever fully settles down--there is potential here for reconciliation.
Read More

Friday, January 22, 2010

Mozilla launches Firefox 3.6, calls it 'world's best browser'

'Users will feel the speed,' says Mozilla exec

Mozilla today released Firefox 3.6, the first upgrade to the open-source browser since last June.

Firefox 3.6 was posted to Mozilla's download servers early Thursday, just over five months after the browser first entered public testing with an alpha release. The upgrade shifted to beta in early November 2009, then wrapped up with a pair of release candidates (RC).

RC2, which reached testers last weekend, was sufficiently bug-free that Mozilla renamed that build as the final it shipped today.

The new browser includes built-in support for the scaled-down browser skins dubbed "Personas;" adds support for new CSS, DOM and HTML 5 technologies, as well as for full-screen video and the open-source Web Open Font Format (WOFF).

Firefox 3.6 also boasts a new security feature that checks browser plug-ins, such as Adobe's Flash Player or Apple's QuickTime, to make sure they're up-to-date, then blocks vulnerable plug-ins from loading and shows users how to update the software. Mozilla added some plug-in checking to older editions starting last September, but fleshed it out in Firefox 3.6.

Mozilla has also boosted the browser's overall performance and reduced its startup time. JavaScript in 3.6 executes approximately 12% faster in Firefox 3.6 than in 3.5, said Mike Beltzner, the director of Firefox, while some pages load up to 20% faster. Other improvements that speed up location bar searches and let Web site designers use asynchronous script loading, are harder to measure, but should give users the feeling that Firefox 3.6 is snappier. "

We did a lot of work with Web developers and with our own code," said Beltzner, "so users will feel the speed."

Mozilla is touting the update with the line, "World's best browser" on its site, an assertion that's likely to raise hackles from the competition. "I believe it's true," said Beltzner, defending the claim. "Firefox lets users take control of their experience, it's the most customizable browser around, and it's an incredibly fast browser. So, from the overall experience [perspective], we think Firefox has the best complete package."

Firefox 3.6 landed about two months later than initial estimates -- last fall, Mozilla said it was shooting for a November delivery of the final -- but the delay was much shorter than the half year the company had to add to the development schedule of Firefox 3.5.

Mozilla has made other changes to its post-3.6 plans. At one time, today's release was to be the first of two minor updates that Mozilla would deliver over a six-month stretch, part of a plan to speed up development and stay feature-competitive with hard-charging rivals such as Google's Chrome. Recently, however, Mozilla has decided to drop the second of those minor updates and instead roll selected features into Firefox 3.6 as part of the year's security updates. Meanwhile, the next major update will go through the standard public testing cycle, and should ship in late 2010 or early 2011.

The appearance of Firefox 3.6 also starts the end-of-life clock ticking for Firefox 3.5; Mozilla's policy is to support an older edition for approximately six months after the launch of a successor, meaning the kill date for 3.5 will likely be in late July 2010. At or around that time, Mozilla will stop producing security patches for the older browser.

Firefox 3.6 can be downloaded in Windows, Mac and Linux editions in 65 languages from Mozilla's site; current users can update by choosing "Check for Updates" under the "Help" menu.
Read More

Friday, January 15, 2010

Mozilla dumps Firefox 3.7 from schedule, changes dev process

Plans to quicken development pace by adding some features via security updates

Mozilla has made major changes to how it develops Firefox, and plans to drop Firefox 3.7 from its schedule and instead roll out incremental changes throughout the year, a company executive said today.

Rather than add features to Firefox only in once- or twice-a-year upgrades, Mozilla will quietly insert some functionality via its regular security updates, which appear every four to six weeks, said Mike Beltzner, director of Firefox, in an interview Thursday.

That means Firefox 3.7, which was slated for a second quarter release, has been dropped from the development schedule, said Beltzner. The next version of the open-source browser after the almost-ready Firefox 3.6 will be an as-yet-unnamed update at the end of this year or in early 2011.

Last year, Mozilla said it would release a pair of fast-track updates, dubbed Firefox 3.6 and Firefox 3.7, that were to take about four or five months each to get out the door. Those so-called "minor updates" would then be followed by Firefox 4.0, a "major update" slated for the last quarter of 2010.

But based on the work on Firefox 3.6, Mozilla's changed its mind.

"I'm proud of how we challenged ourselves," said Beltzner, referring to the quick-strike schedule that Mozilla plotted out for Firefox 3.6, but didn't meet. Mozilla had slated Firefox 3.6 for a November 2009 release, but pushed back the ship date as it worked out bugs and added additional beta builds to the cycle. Firefox 3.6 reached the "release candidate" (RC) stage last week, and should wrap up before the end of this month.

"We learned an awful lot about what slows down our schedule, and that will help us plan future releases," Beltzner said.

In fact, the lessons from Firefox 3.6 led Mozilla to decide to can a release between now and the end of the year, the version previously tagged as Firefox 3.7. Instead, Mozilla will add behind-the-scenes capabilities to Firefox as part of the security updates it does on an irregular schedule every four or more weeks.

Mozilla's developers have been discussing that approach in various mailing lists for some time, and have codenamed the first such update as "Lorentz."

"The first target for [a minor update] will be separation of plug-in processes from the browser," said Beltzner. Mozilla is already working on a project, called "Electrolysis" where Firefox will run each tab as a separate process. The idea is to prevent a single site running in one tab from crashing the entire browser. Google's Chrome, for example, already has this capability.

Rather than wait to complete the entire Electrolysis project, Mozilla will instead separate the processes of specific plug-ins -- Adobe's Flash is the lead candidate -- so that if the plug-in crashes, Firefox itself isn't brought to its knees. According to Beltzner, Flash is responsible for more Firefox crashes than any other plug-in.

"This will be a huge advantage to users," said Beltzner, talking about the Lorentz concept. "We were thinking earlier that the first time we would be able to add [plug-in process separation] would be 3.7 in the middle of the year. But the change we need to make is very isolated, and has no effect on Web compatibility or add-on compatibility or on the user experience. So we thought, 'Why not deliver it as part of a minor update?'"

Up to this point, Mozilla's security updates, which are what Beltzner pegged as minor updates, have delivered patches and at times, stability fixes. They have not, however, added features, either visible or behind the scenes.

Not everything would be fair game for adding to a Firefox security update, Beltzner cautioned, but he said Mozilla was enthusiastic about the idea, which would let it add a "bunch of different technologies" to the browser without having to run through time-consuming beta cycles. Changes that require external testing, such as the planned interface revamp for Firefox on Windows Vista and Windows 7, would still be implemented only in major updates that would go through a standard beta test plan, Beltzner noted.

Firefox 3.6 RC, which is being run by almost one million users, looks "really good," Beltzner said when asked how it's progressing toward final. He acknowledged that there are still bugs developers are investigating, including some that may block a final release and necessitate another release candidate, and so declined to name a ship date.

In meeting notes published to the Mozilla site earlier this week, developers proposed two possible ship dates: Jan. 19 and Jan. 26.
Read More

Monday, December 28, 2009

Mozilla pushes back Firefox 3.6, 4.0 deadlines

Mozilla won't make a 2009 deadline for releasing Firefox 3.6 and is giving itself more time to complete a major update, version 4.0.

The organization behind the open-source Web browser had predicted a final release of Firefox 3.6 in December 2009, but the Mozilla Web site now includes "ship Firefox 3.6" as a goal for the first quarter of 2010.

In addition, Firefox 4.0, which had been due in 2010, now is "aimed at late 2010 or early 2011," with a beta due in the summer of 2010, according to Mozilla.

Schedule delays are common in the software world, but browser development is furious these days with the arrival of Google's Chrome into the market, Apple helping to expand the frontiers of what the browser can do, Opera trying to dramatically speed up JavaScript execution and display performance, and Microsoft getting more ambitious again with Internet Explorer. "We've always been more quality-driven than time-driven, but we understand timing in the market matters to our users and our competitiveness," said Mike Shaver, Mozilla's vice president of engineering, in an October interview.

There's a lot on tap for Firefox, though. The big new feature in version 3.6 is incorporation of the Personas plug-in that lets people easily customize the browser's appearance, though behind the scenes there's also been work to speed up the browser's launch time, improve security, and make some other changes. Mozilla has release five beta versions so far but not the release candidate that signals that work is nearly done; Mozilla programmers are "done with all blockers," bugs or other problems that stand in the way of a release, according to Mozilla's Web site.

So what exactly is coming next for Firefox?

For version 3.7, Mozilla plans several changes. One goal is better performance, for example with a 25 percent reduction in start-up time on Windows. Another is incorporation of Jetpack (now up to version 0.7), an interface for plug-ins that are easier to write, install, and upgrade.

To get quick access to sites that have been bookmarked or previously visited, Firefox already lets people type text into the "awesome bar," formally but hardly ever actually called the smart location bar. Soon to arrive in test versions of Firefox will be a new ability called tab matching that lets people get access also to Web sites already open in other tabs.

Also in development is the first phase of work called Electrolysis to separate various computing processes into separate compartments for better stability. Firefox 3.7 should benefit from the first phase of Electrolysis, which moves plug-ins to a separate process from the main browser computing process.

That should help isolate problems with Adobe Systems' Flash plug-in, for example, that previously crashed the whole browser. However, the initial work only is for Windows and Linux, not Mac OS X.



Another likely addition will be Weave, a plug-in that synchronizes bookmarks, passwords, plug-ins, and open tabs across different instances of Firefox. Weave integration is scheduled for the first quarter of 2010.

For version 4.0, expect deeper changes in Electrolysis to split each browser tabs into a separate process, too. And version 4.0 should get significant user interface changes.

In earlier planning, Mozilla had expected to mimic some of Chrome's design, with tabs across the top of the browser and a location bar below and a menu bar replaced by some drop-down menu buttons that take up less room. Now, in a refresh of the Firefox 4.0 look, Mozilla designer Stephen Horlander introduced a new way to replace the menu bar, the Firefox app button.



In Mozilla's first attempt to replace the menu bar, "we were informed by how Safari and Chrome had handled this problem by paring down all menu items into two separate Page and Tools buttons. This approach has a few advantages but also some disadvantages. The new proposed approach to this problem is an App Button which is similar to the single menu approach taken by Windows 7 native applications (Paint, WordPad) and by MS Office," Horlander said in a blog post.
Read More

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Mozilla unveils Windows theme/UI update for Firefox 3.7/4.0

Mozilla have unveiled some mockups of the Windows theme/UI updates that is scheduled to hit Firefox users over two stages - 3.7 and 4.0.

Stephen Horlander, a designer and contributor to the Mozilla project unveiled some details of the refresh.



Cornerstone to the revamp is the App Button that appears in the top-left of the mockup. Here’s what Horlander has to say about the origin of this new addition:

The new proposed approach to this problem is an App Button which is similar to the single menu approach taken by Windows 7 native applications (Paint, WordPad) and by MS Office.

According to Horlander, the App Button solves a number of issues:
It is less complex
Takes up less space
Instead of two potentially conflicting locations for menu items, there is now only one unified location
Can be placed in the upper left analogous to the Menubar paradigm it is replacing
Similar to the far more ubiquitous Office 2008/2010 + Windows 7 application menu
Reduces clutter on the Navigation Toolbar
It also creates a more flexible and rich canvas for perhaps doing some decidedly non-menu-esque things

Here’s a side-by-side comparison of Firefox 4.0 and the current 3.5:



Mozilla seems to have managed to reclaim a fair bit of screen real estate with this move, which is a good thing. I like it as it really cleans up the user interface.

Expect to see a public release of Firefox 4.0 mid 2010 and the final release during the final quarter.
Read More

Monday, December 21, 2009

Firefox 3.5: World's most popular browser

Data released by StatCounter indicates that Firefox 3.5 is the world’s most popular browser, having edged ahead of Internet Explorer 7.



Looking at the data, it’s possible that Firefox 3.5 will retain the top spot for long as Internet Explorer 8 is catching up fast.

No matter what browser you happen to be a fan of, you have to admit that that Mozilla’s dethroning of Microsoft’s iron grip on the browser chart is very impressive and quite an achievement.

Well done Mozilla!
Read More

Friday, December 18, 2009

Mozilla: Firefox Mobile could be demise of Apple’s App Store, Huh?

We’re not sure if the good people at Mozilla have been drinking the same Kool-Aid® as the folks developing Chrome OS or if they are just out of their blessed minds. Mozilla is touting that its mobile version of Firefox, currently codenamed Fennec, could be the beginning of the end for mobile app stores like Apple’s App Store and Android’s Market. Mozilla VP of mobile Jay Sullivan told PC Pro, “Anyone who knows JavaScript and HTML can develop a great app without having to learn a specific mobile platform.” Now, our memories aren’t that great, but didn’t Apple already try this when the iPhone first came out? Isn’t this what Palm’s entire SDK is made of? Didn’t one Steve Jobs upon launching the first iPhone proclaim, that we don’t need native applications, web apps will do everything we want? So as it turns out, he did, and they didn’t. Sullivan continues, “in the interim period, apps will be very successful. Over time, the web will win because it always does.” Are they visionaries or is it a pipe dream from a company whose bread and butter revolves around the browser? We will see.
Read More

Thursday, December 17, 2009

Mozilla: The "The Web will Win" over App Stores

Mozilla believes that its new Firefox Mobile browser could wean developers away from developing for platform-specific app stores and onto developing cross-platform apps powered by JavaScript and HTML.

Mozilla is starting to take mobile seriously. It is set to release the first version of Firefox Mobile (codenamed Fennec) on Nokia’s N900 handset shortly, with versions for Windows Mobile and Android due to hit handsets next year.

Speaking to PC Pro, Jay Sullivan, vice president of mobile at Mozilla had the following to say:

“Anyone who knows JavaScript and HTML can develop a great app without having to learn a specific mobile platform.”

The problem according to Sullivan is that multiple platforms forces developers to have to recode the app for different platforms:

“You have to create an iPhone app, an Android app, a Windows Mobile app … As developers get more frustrated with quality assurance, the amount of handsets they have to buy, whether their security updates will get past the iPhone approval process … I think they’ll move to the web.”

Sullivan is confident that web-based solutions will triumph over app stores:

“In the interim period, apps will be very successful. Over time, the web will win because it always does.”

While I think that there’s certainly a lot of scope for web-based apps, I can’t see them replacing app stores. Some applications (such as games) just don’t translate to web apps. So while a decent cross-platform browser might ignite interest in web based apps, but it’s unlikely to make much of a dent in app store traffic.

I don’t think Apple executives are going to be losing any sleep over this.
Read More

Wednesday, December 02, 2009

Mozilla adds extra Firefox 3.6 beta, still plans to ship final in 2009

Aims for a release candidate this week

Mozilla last week slipped in a fourth beta of its upcoming Firefox 3.6 browser, but said this week that it is still shooting to ship the final code by the end of the year.

Last Thursday, Mozilla released Firefox 3.6 Beta 4 after developers decided that the browser upgrade needed further testing before moving on to a release candidate.

"Due to the excellent work on knocking down the Firefox 3.6 Beta topcrash list, we've decided that it would be worthwhile to ship another beta update to our close to half million testers to confirm our expectations," Mike Beltzner, the director of Firefox, said in a message posted to the Mozilla developers planning forum last Tuesday. "We'd also like to get as much feedback as possible on the more than 140 fixes we've made since we shipped the update last week."

Mozilla shipped Firefox 3.6 Beta 3 on Nov. 17.

In a follow-up post on the Mozilla developers blog last Thursday, Beltzner bragged that about 70% of the available Firefox add-ons -- a crucial component to the open-source browser's success in grabbing market share from Microsoft's Internet Explorer -- had been upgraded so that they were compatible with Firefox 3.6.

The insertion of the fourth beta has pushed back the delivery of a Firefox 3.6 release candidate, as well as the final code, although Mozilla maintained that it would still wrap up the latter before 2010 begins.

"Closing on blockers in order to deliver a release candidate build this week," Mozilla said in a note published Monday. "Still aiming to be ready to ship in late December."

As recently as September, Mozilla was shooting to deliver the final of Firefox 3.6 by early November. Subsequently, Mozilla began using a before-the-end-of-the-year window to describe its release plans for Firefox 3.6.

Delays are not unusual for Mozilla, or for other software developers. In 2008, for example, Mozilla originally shot for a late-year release of Firefox 3.5, but eventually pushed back the ship date to mid-2009 because it added new features and had trouble closing out some bugs, particularly ones in the then-new TraceMonkey JavaScript engine.

Mozilla has cast Firefox 3.6, and its follow-on 3.7, as minor upgrades driven by a faster-paced development cycle. Firefox 3.7 is to appear in the first half of 2010.

Firefox accounted for 24.7% of all browsers used during November, according to data from Web metrics company Net Applications.

Firefox 3.6 Beta 4 can be downloaded from Mozilla's Web site. People using an earlier preview of Firefox 3.6 should have been automatically upgraded to the newest beta.
Read More

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Mozilla reveals 2008 revenue: $79 million

The Mozilla Foundation's revenue grew 5 percent to $79 million in 2008, with its Firefox search-ad deal with Google still the biggest benefactor, the organization said Thursday.

The figure is notable for an open-source effort, but the growth tapered off significantly. For 2007, by comparison, the Mozilla Foundation reported $75 million in revenue, a 12 percent increase over 2006.

Mozilla Chairman Mitchell Baker revealed the latest Mozilla figures on her blog Thursday.

Firefox has won over about a quarter of the world's users of Web browsers, taking most of that share from Microsoft's still dominant Internet Explorer. The browser faces new challenges, though, in the form of newcomer Google Chrome and Microsoft's resurgent effort to improve Internet Explorer. On Wednesday, Microsoft showed off some elements of the forthcoming IE 9, and Thursday, Google released the source code underlying its Chrome OS, a browser-based operating system for lower-end computers.

Google supplies "the bulk" of the Mozilla Foundation's revenue through a deal that currently lasts through 2011, the foundation said. Under that deal, people performing searches through Firefox using the default Google search engine see and sometimes click on search ads at Google; Google and Mozilla share the resulting revenue. In 2007, Google supplied 89 percent of Mozilla's revenue.

Google isn't the only revenue source, though. Here's how Mozilla described its sources in an FAQ:

"The majority of this revenue is generated from the search functionality in Mozilla Firefox from partners such as Google, Yahoo, Amazon, eBay, and others. Mozilla takes in additional revenue from donations, online affiliate programs, the Mozilla Store, and income on our invested assets. In 2008, we expanded our Firefox partnerships with new firms such as Yandex (Russia Search), Canonical (Ubuntu), and Nokia (Mobile).
Read More